Before I go on, let me say that if you’re sitting there thinking, “I don’t like egg nog” because all you’ve ever had is store-bought nog, give the stuff a second chance. Both of the batches I made were silky smoother (yet still creamy) and far more flavorful than what you’d pick up in the store.
Which brings us to this Thanksgiving.
The food bug has been biting me pretty hard over the last few months. I’d whipped up some Minestrone Soup and several batches of The World’s Best Chocolate Chip Cookies, much to everyone’s delight. And when I needed to get my Amazon order to $25 for free shipping, I dropped in the 10th Anniversary Edition of Mark Bittman’s How To Cook Everything which had just been published that week.
Granted, I only had $3 worth of stuff in my cart to begin with, so maybe I was over-justify a bit. Moving on…
I’d been thinking ahead to the office Christmas party, wanting to bring something other than the fan-favorite Jelly Weiners and it hit me—let’s do egg nog again. I had some store-bought stuff in the fridge that had been tickling my taste buds, including some yummy Pumpkin Spice Egg Nog, but I had a hankering to make something better. I also like to try and add a new dish to holiday meals every so often, so that made Thanksgiving the perfect trial run.
My first stop was Orangette. When someone gives you recipe to The World’s Best Chocolate Cookies, you tend to revere them a bit. Sure enough, she had a recipe that had been passed down over four generations. Sounds good to me! The fact that she called it “beguilingly boozy” only heightened my interest.
But since there would be younglings (and a sober alcoholic) at Thanksgiving, I thought it would be best to also have a kid-friendly batch as well. For that, I ended up following a comment from Orangette’s post to a recipe at The Traveler’s Lunchbox that looked promising.
Recipes and ingredients in hand, I set about on Thanksgiving morn’ to nog some eggs.
I’ll skip the production part and jump straight to the assessment.
J. P. Hartt’s Egg Nog (via Orangette, non-cook): I wouldn’t call this “beguilingly boozy”. I’d call it “unabashedly boozy”. I think you could sterilize medical instrument in this stuff it was so liquor-ful. Which also made it delicious! I made this one first and was pretty happy with it. I think I might tone down the liquor a tad if I made it again (not sure about bringing booze to the at-work office Christmas party), but overall a success.
Top Nog (from The Traveler’s Lunch Box, cooked): Orangette’s was good. This one was amazing. Divine. Transcendent.
This one has a depth imparted by spices instead of booze. And I think the big difference with this one, and pointed to what I was disappointed with all those years ago, was that I think cooked egg nog has a distinct flavor advantage over uncooked.
Keep in mind, I’ve only made egg nog four times (and only three times successfully), but the cooked version has a melding of flavors and a character that the uncooked ones just don’t have. Maybe it’s just a better recipe. Maybe it’s just a taste preference. But I think the cooking has something to do with how it all the flavors come together. Through and through, it has all these little “notes”, to steal from the winos. Synergy!
Needless to say, it was a HUGE hit. Even people who didn’t really care for egg nog said it was good. And I loved the frickin’ stuff.
The trade off is, of course, in time and effort. Non-cooked egg nog can be prepared in a fraction of the time it'll take you to cook (and then chill) the cooked stuff.
All in all, you can’t go wrong with either recipe, although I obviously prefer the Top Nog. And if you wanted to add alcohol to that recipe, go for it! Maybe even take the ratio of liquors (there were four) from Orangette’s and drop it in. No guarantees on how that will change the flavor or the consistency, though. You’re on your own, but let us know if you do it.
In terms of improvement, both were a little thinner than I’d like. When finishing them up in the days following Thanksgiving, I ended up augmenting them with store-bought nog to give them a little more substance. Next time (next week?), I plan on cooking the mixture a bit longer in an effort to thicken it up a bit. We’ll see.
If you’re looking to liven up your next holiday gathering, or just looking to indulge yourself a smidge, I say nog it up. And if doesn’t go as planned, don’t wait 10 years to try again!
Recent Comments